More patients look to unconventional therapies to supplement
their health care. (Karen Caldicott/Special to ABCNEWS.com)
By Claudine Chamberlain
ABCNEWS.com
When she needed two operations on
her ankle, Marcy Foley visited a regular MD. But for her back spasms after
surgery, acupuncture did the trick.
And when her primary care doctor wasn't
able to help her with the disabling vertigo that's kept her out of work
for a year and a half, she turned to naturopathy—with her MD's blessing.
In fact,
Foley has shown up for doctor's appointments to find her naturopath there
as well. "The three of us sit down and talk about my care," she says.
Unlike Foley,
many patients who seek out alternative health care are frowned upon by
their regular physicians. But at Foley's natural medicine clinic—the Kent
Community Health Center in suburban Seattle—cooperation is the name of
the game.
The center
is the nation's first publicly funded clinic to offer natural health care
such as herbal medicine, acupuncture, homeopathy and nutritional counseling.
Two things make the clinic unique: Public subsidies mean that low-income
people finally have access to alternative health care, and the naturopaths
work side by side with MDs.
That marriage
of conventional and unconventional therapies marks a nascent trend: the
integration of natural medicine into mainstream healthcare.
Prodded by
their patients, conventional doctors find themselves boning up on uses
for herbs and vitamins. More and more insurance companies are picking up
the tab for things like massage and acupuncture, especially since a federal
government report last year endorsed certain uses of the Chinese needle
therapy. And the natural-medicine self-treatment boom continues as herbal
supplement sales climb steadily.
Integration
of the two medical disciplines is the current project of physician and
best-selling author Dr. Andrew Weil. At the University of Arizona's College
of Medicine, Weil's Program in Integrative Medicine aims to find ways that
natural medicine can best fit into conventional care.
If They Come,
You'll Build It
Experts agree that the fuel in the
engine of integration is consumer demand.
More than 40 percent of people
surveyed used alternative health care in 1997. Source: Landmark Healthcare
Inc. (ABCNEWS.com) |
Typical patients don't like
being rushed through 15-minute doctor's exams. They don't like the idea
of heavy-duty drugs if there's an herb that can help them with fewer side
effects. And they want to be more involved in their own health care.
"There are
situations where herbs and diet can really make an impact," says Dr. Cindy
Breed, a naturopath at the Kent clinic. "It would be foolish not to try
those things. Why go with the hammer when you can use something that's
less hard on the person?"
Many of Breed's
patients, like Marcy Foley, also receive care from conventional medical
doctors. "There are some situations where it's six of one, half a dozen
of another," Breed says. "It's really important to be able to ask the patient
what their heart tells them they want to do."
Western medicine's
wake-up call came in January 1993, when Harvard physician David Eisenberg
published a landmark study of alternative health care in The New England
Journal of Medicine. In 1990, the year Eisenberg did his survey, Americans
made 425 million visits to alternative care providers such as chiropractors,
acupuncturists and massage therapists. Compare that to 388 million visits
to primary care physicians that same year, and you get quite a few startled
doctors.
And it is
startling, especially when you consider that the vast majority of those
visits are being paid for directly out of the patients' pockets. Americans
fork over roughly $10 billion a year of their own money on alternative
care.
Managed Care
Takes Note
With that kind of demand, the health
care industry can't help but respond. At least 50 of the 125 medical schools
in the United States now offer classes in unconventional therapies, although
enrollment is still low and the curricula vary widely.
Notable managed
care organizations—Oxford Health Plan, Blue Shield of California, Kaiser
Permanente of California and Group Health Co-op of Puget Sound in Washington
state—now subsidize some natural health care. Under the Oxford plan, you
don't even need to ask your primary care doctor for permission first.
If integration
of natural and conventional medicine does prove to be the wave of the future,
experts say it's patients like Marcy Foley who will benefit.
Most people use alternative care
along with conventional health care. Source: Landmark Healthcare Inc.
(ABCNEWS.com) |
Herbs and yoga can't treat
everything, but neither can drugs and surgery. By working together, naturopaths
and MDs can find the best approach for each patient.
Since Dr.
Breed began treating her vertigo with cranial sacral therapy—a sort of
laying on of hands that's similar to massage and aims to regulate the flow
of a fluid that circulates within the head and up and down the spine—Foley's
gone for four weeks without an attack. Previously, her record had been
three weeks.
Even if it
turns out that this therapy doesn't help her, Foley is happy knowing that
at least she wasn't shut out from that option by a conservative medical
system. "It's such a vital thing," she says, "that you can have the treatment
that you really desire and you really feel is going to help you." |